The only all-inclusive in the world simultaneously holding Forbes Five Stars, AAA Five Diamonds, and a MICHELIN-starred restaurant — a genuine distinction, not a marketing claim
Cocina de Autor's 8-10 course tasting menu with wine pairing is fully included in the all-inclusive rate — at a standalone restaurant this would cost hundreds per person
Every suite starts at 1,081 sq ft with ocean views, private terrace jacuzzi, and 24-hour butler concierge — the entry suite here exceeds most competitors' top categories
Three-tier infinity pools naturally segregate family, activity, and adult-only zones without restricting access — practical design rather than strict policy
Cons
Beach is not swimmable — Los Cabos Pacific currents make ocean swimming dangerous; the infinity pools are where guests actually swim
Cocina de Autor is restricted to adults and guests 18+ — families with younger children can't access the MICHELIN-starred restaurant during their stay
Rates start around $1,600/night in low season and $1,800+ in peak winter — a significant commitment that requires being genuinely invested in the Five Diamond experience to justify
St. James's Club & Villas
Pros
Two entirely different beaches on opposite sides of the peninsula is unusual and practically useful — most all-inclusives offer one beach environment with limited variation.
The 2-bedroom (1,600 sq ft) and 3-bedroom (2,000 sq ft) villa configurations make St. James's Club viable for multi-family bookings in a way hotel-room-only properties aren't.
Complimentary non-motorized water sports including Hobie Cat sailing are genuinely comprehensive — more than most Caribbean all-inclusives include at no extra charge.
Afternoon tea in the garden is a charming and distinctive British colonial touch that guests consistently mention positively.
Cons
Wi-Fi is persistently unreliable — plan for limited connectivity and don't book this property if reliable internet access is a work requirement.
Summary
Grand Velas Los Cabos has a higher guest rating, while Grand Velas Los Cabos has more restaurants, while Grand Velas Los Cabos is the larger property, while St. James's Club & Villas has more dining venues.
Buffet food quality has temperature and consistency complaints — arrive early in service periods for the best results.
Room maintenance issues (fixtures, hot water, cleanliness in some rooms) appear in a subset of reviews — request a room inspection if something isn't right on arrival.
The late 2025/early 2026 renovation of Beachfront Rooms, Royal Suites, and Piccolo Mondo may affect stay experience during that window.
