AAA Five Diamond and Forbes Five-Star simultaneously — one of the most decorated all-inclusive resorts in Mexico
Suites start at 1,000 sq ft with private terraces, ocean views, and 24-hour butler concierge — the entry level here exceeds most competitors' premium categories
Premium spirits, wines, and 24-hour room service are fully included — not standard at most all-inclusives, even premium ones
Banderas Bay is swimmable — actual ocean swimming possible, unlike Los Cabos Pacific corridor properties
Cons
Pool lounger competition peaks by 8 AM in high season (December through March) — early rising is required for preferred positions
Some ocean view suites have partial obstructions from palm trees or the Selva del Mar restaurant building — ask at booking about specific suite positioning
Piaf and Frida fill up during high season — book before arrival rather than assuming walk-in availability
St. James's Club & Villas
Pros
Two entirely different beaches on opposite sides of the peninsula is unusual and practically useful — most all-inclusives offer one beach environment with limited variation.
The 2-bedroom (1,600 sq ft) and 3-bedroom (2,000 sq ft) villa configurations make St. James's Club viable for multi-family bookings in a way hotel-room-only properties aren't.
Complimentary non-motorized water sports including Hobie Cat sailing are genuinely comprehensive — more than most Caribbean all-inclusives include at no extra charge.
Afternoon tea in the garden is a charming and distinctive British colonial touch that guests consistently mention positively.
Cons
Wi-Fi is persistently unreliable — plan for limited connectivity and don't book this property if reliable internet access is a work requirement.
Buffet food quality has temperature and consistency complaints — arrive early in service periods for the best results.
Room maintenance issues (fixtures, hot water, cleanliness in some rooms) appear in a subset of reviews — request a room inspection if something isn't right on arrival.
Summary
Grand Velas Riviera Nayarit has a higher guest rating, while Grand Velas Riviera Nayarit has more restaurants, while Grand Velas Riviera Nayarit is the larger property, while St. James's Club & Villas has more dining venues, while St. James's Club & Villas offers more activities.
